Oh don't get me started on the inconsistencies in Reid's character... an endless thread of swearing and keyboard smashing would ensue... >:/
I prefer a critical, thinking fanbase over the squee-ing type, but one has to occasionally take a step back and remember what the hell it is you are critiquing in the first place. The type of behavior that has driven me from fandom in the past are hysterical, delusional rants (usually as a form of protection over a favorite character or actor) or a sense of fandom entitlement over show direction. Yep, I'm angry at the writers sometimes but that does not mean that I'd ever start a Twitter harassment campaign or try to contact actors/producers directly (I've watched this happen in other fandoms - horrifying). There's a level of meta that I can handle and anything past that squicks the hell out of me.
But, yeah, I enjoy talking about the show (both good and bad) - I just don't get how conversation works on tumblr (once again, showing my age...). Since I'm not on tumblr and only lurk in a few CM comms here on lj, I'm not getting a very wide view of the fanbase. We seem a bit... passive here, but if you say that fans are more vocal on tumblr, I'll take your word for it. Do you find that the prevailing opinion over there to be positive or negative regarding where the show is now? Just by what I've read in this one posting, it appears that many fans have problems with the same key issues (violence and characterization).
![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png){kind=small}
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
momijizukamori
no subject
Date: Mar. 12th, 2014 02:29 pm (UTC)I prefer a critical, thinking fanbase over the squee-ing type, but one has to occasionally take a step back and remember what the hell it is you are critiquing in the first place. The type of behavior that has driven me from fandom in the past are hysterical, delusional rants (usually as a form of protection over a favorite character or actor) or a sense of fandom entitlement over show direction. Yep, I'm angry at the writers sometimes but that does not mean that I'd ever start a Twitter harassment campaign or try to contact actors/producers directly (I've watched this happen in other fandoms - horrifying). There's a level of meta that I can handle and anything past that squicks the hell out of me.
But, yeah, I enjoy talking about the show (both good and bad) - I just don't get how conversation works on tumblr (once again, showing my age...). Since I'm not on tumblr and only lurk in a few CM comms here on lj, I'm not getting a very wide view of the fanbase. We seem a bit... passive here, but if you say that fans are more vocal on tumblr, I'll take your word for it. Do you find that the prevailing opinion over there to be positive or negative regarding where the show is now? Just by what I've read in this one posting, it appears that many fans have problems with the same key issues (violence and characterization).